I Believe in Manicures | So do I, Audrey, so do I. This is not quite the Tiffany blue shade because it's icier and paler, but it goes on smooth and is so much nicer to apply than the original collection. I think you'll find the general sentiment that Infinite Shine ALWAYS wins in my books.
Girls Love Pearls | This is a frosty white pearl that goes on pretty streaky and is too grandma-ish for my liking.
Party at Holly's | This is about the only shade I really like in the collection. It's a deep vampy burgundy that looks almost black-brown.
Can't Tame a Wild Thing | This is an orange creme. I don't really describe it as a red because it is just so bright and yellow toned. I don't like these ones on me, but the formulation is great!
Ring the Buzzer Again | Just a classic red. I feel like the Infinite Shine part of this collection was too redundant to be entirely on its own.
I'll Have a Manhattan | This one is a nice dark purple creme that goes on smoothly and doesn't look black. It definitely is a true purple and has more blue tones rather than red.